Skip to content
Resources · Your rights

Has the justice system failed you?

When the courts, the police or the offices meant to protect you leave you unheard, it hurts in a particular way. This page is about what is happening, what the Constitution promises, and how to look after your mind while you keep going.

To the person reading this.

You went to court for maintenance, and you are still waiting. You laid a charge, and no one ever called you back. You got a protection order, and it wasn’t enforced. Your docket went missing. Your file was “lost”. Your case was postponed again, and again, and again. And the people deciding your future and your children’s future don’t know you. They don’t care about you. They never once really listened to you. Yet they are the ones deciding your future.

You did everything right. You followed the rules. You trusted the system to protect you and your children, and it didn’t.

If you feel exhausted, furious, ashamed, or as if you are going mad, hear this clearly: you are not going mad. You are not too emotional, too difficult or too much. What you are feeling is a normal human response to being betrayed by the very system that promised to protect you.

The failure is not yours. It belongs to the system.

I believe you.

You don’t have to do this alone. Talk to a counsellor who understands, or connect with people who have lived it through Divorce Recovery with Heather O’Shea (@divorcerecovery2).

Why I wrote this.

I am a counsellor with more than twenty years of practice. I am also a mother who has spent years in the courts fighting for my children.

I have been laughed at by magistrates and maintenance officers. It didn’t happen once. It happened over and over, until I lodged an official complaint with the Public Protector. I have stood in courtrooms and watched the law, and the Constitution itself, not being applied.

I have lost years to court corridors, and those years belonged to my children. Time I should have spent with them, at their school events and around the dinner table, went into postponements, affidavits and letters nobody answered. The business I built has been drained to pay lawyers I still owe money to, and after all of it I am no further than where I started. Again and again it has felt like having my head slammed against a brick wall.

And this is not new for me. The system failed me when I was a child, and it kept failing me. Now, as an adult and a mother, here I am again, and the system has not changed one bit.

I am not sharing names or case details here, because some of my matters are still before the courts. But I will tell you what saved me. It wasn’t a judgment or a ruling. It was talking to people who believed me, because they had been through exactly what I had been through. They didn’t need me to explain or prove anything. They just knew.

That is why this page exists.

“Everyone has inherent dignity and the right to have their dignity respected and protected.”

Section 10, Constitution of the Republic of South Africa

This is what happens. This is what the Constitution says.

The Constitution is very clear. The Bill of Rights binds the courts, the police, the maintenance office and every government department. Section 7 says the state must respect, protect, promote and fulfil these rights. That means always, and not only when it is convenient.

Your dignity

What happens: You are laughed at, spoken down to, kept waiting for hours, or treated as a case number.

What it says: Section 10: everyone has inherent dignity, and the right to have it respected and protected.

Equal treatment

What happens: The person with more money or a better lawyer seems to get heard first.

What it says: Section 9: everyone is equal before the law and has the right to equal protection and benefit of the law.

Safety of body and mind

What happens: Abuse is reported, but nothing changes. You don’t feel safe.

What it says: Section 12: everyone has the right to be free from all forms of violence, and to bodily and psychological integrity.

Your mental health

What happens: The stress of the process makes you ill, and help feels out of reach.

What it says: Section 27: everyone has the right of access to health care services. The Mental Health Care Act 17 of 2002 protects the dignity and rights of people who use mental health services.

Your children

What happens: Maintenance goes unpaid, matters are postponed again and again, and children carry the cost.

What it says: Section 28: a child’s best interests are of paramount importance in every matter concerning the child. That means the child comes first, ahead of the court’s convenience and ahead of the parent with deeper pockets.

A fair hearing

What happens: Postponements, lost files and letters that are never answered.

What it says: Section 34: everyone has the right to have a dispute decided in a fair public hearing. Section 33: everyone has the right to administrative action that is lawful, reasonable and procedurally fair, and to written reasons when their rights are affected.

Officials who answer to you

What happens: Officials brush you off, mock you, or never explain their decisions.

What it says: Section 195: public administration must maintain a high standard of professional ethics, respond to people’s needs, and be accountable and transparent.

Who is benefiting?

When a system fails the same people over and over, for years, we have to start asking an honest question: who benefits from it staying this way? It isn’t the mothers waiting in corridors, and it isn’t the children whose maintenance goes unpaid. Every postponement means another legal bill, another lost day of work and another month a child goes without. We need to start asking who gains from a system that moves this slowly.

What being let down does to your mind.

Psychologists call it institutional betrayal: harm done when an institution you depend on fails to protect you. When it follows abuse, a crime or a loss, it is often called secondary victimisation. It can hurt as much as the original event.

You might notice sleeplessness, a racing mind, anger that comes out of nowhere, numbness, or a feeling that nothing you do matters. You might replay hearings and letters in your head. Many people start drinking more, withdrawing, or turning the anger on themselves. I know every one of these from the inside.

Debrief with MyTruth

After a hearing, a hard meeting or another letter that goes unanswered, you don’t have to carry it home alone. A debriefing session with a MyTruth counsellor gives you space to offload what happened, make sense of it and steady yourself before the next step.

Looking after yourself while you keep going.

  • Breathe and ground before and after. Before a hearing or a hard phone call, slow your breathing and feel your feet on the floor. The wave of panic or anger will pass.
  • Keep a record. Write down dates, reference numbers, who you spoke to and what was said. It protects you, and it gets the noise out of your head.
  • Find your people. Talk to someone who has walked this road. Isolation is what makes the system feel all-powerful, and being believed is what breaks that.
  • Separate the process from your worth. A delayed or unfair outcome says something about the system, not about you or your truth.
  • Get support for you. Legal help fights the case. Counselling helps you survive it.
  • Start each day with a reminder. On the hard days it is easy to forget your truth. Sign up for a free affirmation every day to help you stand strong.

Know your truth.

No matter what anyone says, know your truth and believe YOU. A magistrate laughing, a missing file or an unanswered letter does not change what happened to you or what you know. You have you, no matter what.

You are not alone. I believe you.

We will not stop.

This has to change for our children, for our daughters and for our sons. I will not stop fighting, and I am asking you to stand with me. Stand together. Be loud about system failure. Stand strong in what the Constitution clearly states. One voice can be ignored, but many voices together cannot.

This page is general information, not legal advice. For advice on your own matter, speak to an attorney or Legal Aid South Africa.

Where you can turn

These bodies were set up under the Constitution and the law to hold the system to account. Search for their official websites for contact details.

Divorce Recovery with Heather O’Shea (@divorcerecovery2)

Heather is an advocate who speaks out about system failure in the family courts. Her community is a place to be heard by people who understand divorce, court battles and the fight for your children because they have been through it themselves.

South African Human Rights Commission

Investigates complaints that your constitutional rights, including dignity and equality, have been violated.

Public Protector

Investigates maladministration and improper conduct by government departments and officials. I have lodged a complaint here myself.

Legal Aid South Africa

Free legal help for people who cannot afford an attorney, including in family and civil matters.

Judicial Conduct Committee

Part of the Judicial Service Commission. Receives complaints about the conduct of judges.

Office of the Family Advocate

Helps courts protect the best interests of children in divorce, care and contact matters.

Commission for Gender Equality

Investigates gender-based discrimination, including how women are treated by public institutions.

Talk to people who have been there

What saved me was being believed by people who had lived it. You can find that too.

Talking to people with lived experience can be unbelievably helpful. They understand what it is like when there seems to be no justice. You don’t have to convince them, defend yourself or start from the beginning. They have sat in the same corridors and read the same unanswered letters. Being believed by someone who has lived it can give you back the strength the system took from you.

The MyTruth Circle is our free WhatsApp community. A safe space for women who have been failed by the system. You are not alone. We believe you.

Members of the community can see your phone number.

What the Constitution and the law say about peer support

  • Section 18: everyone has the right to freedom of association. You have the right to come together with others who share your experience.
  • Section 16: everyone has the right to freedom of expression. You have the right to speak about what has happened to you.
  • Section 17: everyone has the right to assemble peacefully, to demonstrate and to present petitions.
  • UN Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities: South Africa has ratified it, and Article 26 names peer support as one of the ways states should help people with psychosocial disabilities live fully and independently. Section 39 of the Constitution says courts must consider international law when they interpret the Bill of Rights.
  • National Mental Health Policy Framework and Strategic Plan 2023–2030: recognises the role of community-based organisations and NGOs in widening access to mental health support.

You deserve to be heard.

The system may be slow to listen. We won’t be. Talk to a counsellor who knows what it is like to fight for your rights and your family, online and in your language.

Your truth deserves to be heard.

Choose a counsellor who speaks your language and understands your world. Sessions are online, private and booked in minutes.

Book a sessionWhatsApp